|
Feature
|
CAT
|
RCA
|
HSRCA
|
| Weight
& portability |
Portable,
7kg instrument, 11kg when in case. Operated by one person |
Not
portable: train mounted |
Not
portable: train mounted |
| Measuring
speed |
Walking
speed: 2-5km/h |
Up to
20km/h demonstrated |
Typically
60-100km/h; lower speed possible with reduced accuracy, particularly
at long wavelengths |
| Measuring
principle |
Contacting
transducer |
Contacting
transducer |
Axlebox
accelerometers |
| Measurement
of |
Single
rail |
Both
rails simultaneously |
Both
rails simultaneously |
| Requirements
regarding train or vehicle |
None:
portable system |
Minimal
wheel irregularities |
Minimal
wheel irregularities Electronic tachometer Good primary suspension:
minimal friction elements |
| Typical
accuracy in 30-100mm wavelength range |
Better
than 0.001mm RMS |
Better
than 0.010mm RMS |
Better
than 0.015mm RMS |
| Computing
requirements |
Laptop,
75MHz Pentium or better |
Laptop
or desktop, 75MHz Pentium or better |
Desktop,
500MHz or better |
| Software |
Proprietary,
Windows based |
Proprietary,
Windows based |
Proprietary,
Windows based |
| Data
collection, signal processing & display [1] |
-
Profile of one rail at 1mm or 2mm interval and 0.01 micron
resolution
- Filtered profiles [2]
- RMS amplitudes in “block” or moving window [2]
- Peak-to-peak amplitudes in block or moving window [2]
- Percentage exceedence [4]
- One-third octave band spectra |
-
Profile of both rails at 2mm interval and 1 micron resolution
- Filtered profiles [2]
- RMS amplitudes in “block” or moving window [2]
- Peak-to-peak amplitudes in block or moving window [2]
- Percentage exceedence [4] |
- RMS
amplitudes in “block” [3]
- Percentage exceedence [4,5] |
| Automatic
detection discrete irregularities (e.g. welds) |
No |
No |
Yes,
ranked into up to 7 ranges of severity |
| Annotation
of records with features of line (bridges, etc.) |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
| Annotation
of records with features of line (bridges, etc.) |
-
Corrugation surveys and troubleshooting
- Quality Assurance for grinding
- Accurate measurement of short lengths of track (2- 5km/h)
- Measurements for acoustics work
- Verification and calibration of other equipment, e.g. RCA and
HSRCA |
-
Corrugation surveys for metros or other relatively small railway
systems
- Quality assurance for grinding
- Accurate measurement of moderate lengths of track |
-
Measurement of complete rail systems to assess grinding requirements |